What would you recommend to anglers fishing in Islamorada, Florida for the first time?

Answers by verified BoatBooker customers who went boating in Islamorada

Sort by:
Sort by: Recommended
Showing:
1 - 30 of 32 answers
customer-avatar
Richard Hagger
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Custom Charters on June 22, 2026
The Captain is highly focused on safety and communication. Listen to his briefing details on safety, boat features, and most of all where you want to go and what you want to see. And don't forget sunscreen!! Have an awesome time.

customer-avatar
Danelle Briske
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Bamboo Charters on June 19, 2026
Make sure you are using reef safe sunscreen, stay hydrated, water is very clear but there will likely be seaweed/sargassum floating on top of the water, which doesn’t stink in the water, just swim around it.

customer-avatar
Jaime Field
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Islamorada Private Charters on May 24, 2026
Islamorada Private Charters Captain Donald Tait Not a catamaran was double booked didn’t have are reservation but was charged and confirmed had to show screen shot and than told wait hour had 40 foot boat which was ridiculous pontoon boat for 50 people not 3 Didn’t offer to discount try to accommodate but honestly for what we paid was so disappointing and would never recommend this captain and his team. He should have been so apologetic. I went through website had no idea it was different than his direct site was charged and had confirmation which was confirmed. Nice to be on the water and it’s such a beautiful place. 450.00 for the wrong boat and waited all day wasn’t worth it.

customer-avatar
Timothy Manchester
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Bamboo Charters on May 29, 2026
Yes, charter had it all—just show up and enjoy the beauty of the Keys. Captain Matt did a great job.

customer-avatar
Ellen PARROTT
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Islamorada Private Sandbar & Snorkel Charters on May 19, 2026
Definitely go to the sandbar, and on the way home stop by Robbies and feed the Tarpon and have a delicious Margarita!

customer-avatar
Brian Mclean
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Reef Quest Tours on April 9, 2026
Early April may be windy, which can impact tours, you may want to wait until you get here to book, because the forecast is rarely accurate more than a day in advance. Sightseeing/sand bar trips are likely less impacted than snorkeling/fishing trips.

customer-avatar
Blake Norris
Key West, Florida
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Islamorada Luxe Charters – Islamorada Sandbar on June 21, 2026
Known for their water but not the beaches you would think. Be prepared for the iguanas on dry land

customer-avatar
Charissa Maguire
VERIFIED  
Went boating with SeaEO IV - Key Largo/ Islamorada - Luxury Boa on June 23, 2026
Bring everything you need including food, anti-nausea medicine, and plenty if water.

customer-avatar
Lisa Boyum
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Islamorada Private Charters on May 7, 2026
Highly recommend going on at least one excursion! Even a short snorkel trip is well worth it!!

customer-avatar
Joan Maudlin
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Keys Aquatic Adventures on June 21, 2025
It was windy. Not sure if that is always the case for June. Water was extremely clear and beautiful

customer-avatar
Melanie Bryant
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Bamboo Charters on June 20, 2025
The captain is easy to communicate with so if you have special needs or requests, just make them known beforehand.

customer-avatar
Kristina Martinez
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Island Ryder Charters on June 6, 2025
Enjoy the most relaxing of days on the Family Sandbar. Bring lunch together with your closest friends & family. Captain Jen will listen, guide, and offer the best experience.

customer-avatar
Curt Bigelow
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Islamorada Private Charters on May 6, 2025
Book with someone who knows the waters and conditions. Captain Don was extremely knowledgeable of the area, waters, and conditions.

customer-avatar
Neysa Mcdonald
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Keys Aquatic Adventures on March 17, 2025
For us, from up north, water temp was perfect :) Charlie very knowledgeable and we had a great time!!

customer-avatar
Nancy Sudmann
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Bamboo Charters on December 24, 2024
We were hoping to snorkel but water temp was too cold for us! But not bad just boating around on the water with sweatshirt on during Christmas time!

customer-avatar
Ryan O'Shea
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Bamboo Charters on March 6, 2025
Being from Wisconsin, cooler temps don't bother us as much as others. The strength of the wind plays the biggest role in how warm it feels. We had a pretty windy day with highs in the low 70s but we still very much enjoyed the charter.

customer-avatar
Heather Mcallister
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Islamorada Private Charters on March 4, 2025
My friend and I took the 2 hour boat tour for her birthday. Our boat captain Donald was such a pleasure to deal with. He was very professional, fun and took us to all the cool spots. We had an amazing time amongst the dolphins ? and he also showed us the best places to watch the sunset. I highly recommended this boat tour.

customer-avatar
Tesla Prigge
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Islamorada Private Sandbar & Snorkel Charters on February 12, 2026
Go to alligator reef lighthouse and go snorkeling! Once in a lifetime trip! ? ?

customer-avatar
Katy Dabill
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Islamorada Private Sandbar & Snorkel Charters on December 26, 2025
Little windier than I expected, bring layers. Water might be cold at first but you adjust quickly.

customer-avatar
Lisa Carlotta
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Nautical Tiki Islamorada on July 22, 2025
Great trip for the money. Captain is conscious of pricing, especially for families.

customer-avatar
Danielle (dani) Ramsey
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Nautical Tiki Islamorada on June 24, 2025
Such a great time! Fun to cruise on a tiki boat and people left with full hearts!

customer-avatar
Kristal Hemphill
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Keys Aquatic Adventures on April 7, 2025
It was too windy to go to the lighthouse and snorkel but Captain Charlie made the best of it!

customer-avatar
Timothy Nelson
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Bamboo Charters on April 8, 2026
This was an absolute fantastic time! Captain Eddie went above and beyond, and I cannot thank him enough!

customer-avatar
Preston Fewkes
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Islamorada Private Sandbar & Snorkel Charters on April 6, 2026
This time of year was windy so visibility for snorkeling was very bad. But the temperatures were really nice.

customer-avatar
Lisa Smith
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Islamorada Private Charters on March 20, 2026
This company was awesome and easy to work with! Atlantis our captain was knowledgable and made a great day for us!

customer-avatar
Teresa Johnson
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Bamboo Charters on February 26, 2026
It was so much fun to see the area by boat. The color of the water was gorgeous.

customer-avatar
Thomas Carman
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Reef Quest Tours on February 21, 2026
Book with Reef Quest Tours and don’t hesitate to ask questions. They are clearly committed to you having a safe and enjoyable experience

customer-avatar
Morgan Bisienere
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Islamorada Private Charters on February 12, 2026
Wild life is awesome on it . Make sure you check the weather 3 days prior so you know if you need to cancel . We happen to have a beautiful Florida day

customer-avatar
Mark Johnson
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Bamboo Charters on December 29, 2025
Ask every question you have. You are safe and bamboo charters will ensure you're ready to get in thevwater

customer-avatar
Frank Staszesky
VERIFIED  
Went boating with Bamboo Charters on August 6, 2025
Water is nice and warm. Truck is to go out as early as possible to have the best chance of avoiding the inevitable thunderstorms this time of year.