Jen Byrnes
Jen Byrnes
nl
Netherlands
Member since 2026
3.3
Verified

Great Capitain, bad booking agent

3 Hour – Sunset Cruise6 adults

We booked a sunset cruise, we had a misunderstanding at first because the boat was in Malta and we were staying in Gozo. The agent was helpful and we rescheduled. Before booking I made sure the boat had disabled access. They assured me it did, unforunately it did not, and my mother and father were unable to board. This worked out because about 10 minutes into our cruise the boat broke down we needed to be towed in and had to disembark into a smaller boat. Our capitan Peter and his son were lovely and handled the problem safely and profeasionally. Here is where things went sour. I requested a full refund, but was only offered 75 %. We agreeed to this in hopes that the 25% would go to captain Peter for his expenses. When I asked about a full refund, the agent had a list of reasons why 75% was generous. Including making up false claims that we kept him waiting for an hour. We were more than happy to pay for the wine and snacks we ordered. They also claimed they could not refund to our cc only a bank acct. This of course turned out to be a lie and had to push them to refund the original payment method. Extremly disappoined, would not recommed usimg this booking agent.

Response from Captain

Thank you for your feedback. We are disappointed to read this review because we do not believe it is a fair or accurate reflection of what happened. Your original booking could not proceed because the boat was in Malta while you travelled to Gozo. We were only informed of this approximately one hour before the scheduled departure, leaving us with no opportunity to rebook the charter. Despite this, we did not charge you for the missed charter. Instead, with your agreement, we arranged an alternative charter with a trusted partner in Gozo so that your family could still enjoy their holiday. Under normal circumstances, we are also able to accommodate departures from Gozo with our own boat. However, as this was a short three-hour sunset charter, it was simply not possible to organise the necessary repositioning at such short notice. We also made every reasonable effort to assist your parents with boarding. Unfortunately, due to the busy harbour conditions on the day, embarking proved more difficult than anticipated. After discussing the situation, your group chose to proceed with the charter. Shortly after departure, an unexpected mechanical issue occurred. Captain Peter immediately prioritised everyone's safety, arranged assistance, and returned to harbour. Before returning, refreshments, including Prosecco, wine and snacks, had already been served. We agreed to refund 75% of the charter price, and this resolution was accepted by you at the time. The remaining 25% simply covered part of the costs already incurred for the food and drinks that had already been consumed during the charter. We therefore find it disappointing that this agreed settlement is now being portrayed differently. Finally, after posting this review, you contacted us stating that you would remove it if we paid the remaining 25% of the charter price. We declined because we had already honoured the refund that had been mutually agreed. We believe reviews should reflect genuine customer experiences and not be contingent upon additional payments after a settlement has already been reached. We have no ill feelings towards you or your family, and we genuinely wish you all the very best. We have replied solely in the interest of full transparency for anyone reading this review. It is important to us that the full circumstances are understood and that the facts are presented accurately. We have no bone of contention with you, we simply felt it was necessary to respond truthfully so that readers can understand the complete picture.

Compare similar fishing charters

Current
Private Sailing Yacht Charter – Presto
4.8
/5
50 reviews
44 ft
Group size 1 - 11
1 - 11
4 hour trip • 8 persons
US $524

Rating

4.8
50 reviews
4.8
Boat & Equipment
4.9
Captain & Crew
4.7
Boating Experience

What boaters say

  • 94%
    Family friendly
  • 94%
    Friendly captain
  • 88%
    Good boat
  • 96%
    Recommended

All reviews (50)

Showing 2630 of 50 reviews
  • Elizabeth Faidley
    Elizabeth Faidley
    us
    New Jersey, US
    Member since 2025
    3.7
    Verified

    Eh...bare minimum

    8 Hour – Private Day Trip2 adults

    Our skipper was competent and made sure everything ran safely, but overall the experience felt quite minimal for the price. Nothing was wrong, but there was very little engagement or guidance. He did not explain where we were, what we might see, or offer any interaction beyond the basics. We had mentioned a few requests before heading out, but they were not really addressed. Considering the high cost of the trip we had expected a bit more in terms of enthusiasm, local insight, or hospitality. The experience was fine, but not at the level we hoped for. I wanted to share this as constructive feedback and I sent it to the owner, Neal, who really did not seem to care. We appreciate the service, but think that a little more attention or interaction from the skipper could make a big difference for future guests. If you want an experience where the skipper gets in the water, tells you where you are going, helps you explore beautiful Malta, I'd look elsewhere. We snorkel around the world frequently and this one came up very short. We even asked to end the tour 3-4 hours early....... never done that before.

    Response from Captain

    Hi Elizabeth, Thank you for sharing your feedback. We’re genuinely sorry that the experience didn’t meet what you were hoping for. We always do our utmost to make every trip special, comfortable, and tailored to our guests’ wishes. For safety reasons, skippers are required to remain on board at all times, but had we known you wanted a more interactive or in-water experience, we would have gladly arranged an additional crew member for this. For your charter, we were happy to accommodate your specific requests — including changing the pick-up location after the booking, which involved travelling two hours to meet you. Please rest assured that your message was received and appreciated — we do care deeply about every guest’s experience. We wish you all the best on your future travels and thank you again for choosing to sail with us.

  • Ed Worton
    Ed Worton
    us
    New Jersey, US
    Member since 2025
    5.0
    Verified

    Perfect Day on the Water

    8 Hour – Private Day Trip2 adults

    My husband and I came to Malta for our honeymoon, and our one splurge was to charter a boat to see some of Malta’s aquatic wonders. Janko was our captain, and he was informative, friendly, and funny. He brought us to all the spots we wanted to see, and even showed us some hidden gems where we were able to snorkel and paddle board. He prepared us food on the boat for lunch, and gave us information and recommendations for things to do and see while on land as well. We had a 10/10 experience.

  • Martina Kaposvári
    Martina Kaposvári
    hu
    Hungary
    Member since 2025
    5.0
    Verified

    Memory for a lifetime

    8 Hour – Private Day Trip7 adults

    We had a fantastic full-day private boat trip with Neal. He was waiting for us right on time at the agreed location, and the boat was spacious, clean, modern, and very comfortable. We cruised through stunning locations with crystal-clear water and stopped in beautiful bays where we could swim. Although the water was still a bit cold in April, the kids enjoyed swimming and even spotted some fish. Neal was a kind and skilled captain — he even cooked us a lovely lunch in one of the bays. Highly recommended!

  • David Burton
    David Burton
    gb
    United Kingdom
    Member since 2025
    5.0
    Verified

    Wonderful Day at Sea

    8 Hour – Private Day Trip2 adults

    From the beginning to when we disembarked the whole experience was easy with frequent contact from Captain Neal. On the day we were lucky enough to have Sondre from Norway as our Captain. What a superstar! He couldn’t have been nicer and made our day. The barbecue fish was beautiful and we thoroughly enjoyed our lunch. Myself and Mum had a great day and definitely the pinnacle of our time in Malta.

  • Maria Graham
    Maria Graham
    us
    Michigan, US
    Member since 2025
    5.0
    Verified

    THE BEST DAY EVER!

    8 Hour – Private Day Trip3 adults

    From Neil’s communication to prep for our trip, to Steve’s captain-ship - my cousins and I had the most amazing experience. We will be sharing their information with our family that has yet to come, and we will 100% be back, just for this experience. Thanks for the day, the laughs, the education, the meal, the kindness and the memories! Love, the Malta Marias and Dave