Caisey Rodgers
Caisey Rodgers
us
Port St. Joe, FL, US
Member since 2025
5.0
Verified

Perfect Trip

6 Hour Trip4 adults

We booked Why Not during our spring break. There were four of us, myself, my husband, 15 year old son and his best friend. We are from the coast in FL and all fish regularly. We booked with Pedro a 6 hour excursion. The plan was to go fishing a little and then go snorkeling. We had clear communication of where to meet and jumped straight onto the boat. In no time, they were putting lines in the water. Unfortunately it was very rough and I just couldn’t handle it. I tried to hold off because they were working so hard to get us a fish on the line. Once they realized I was sick, they quickly came up with a new plan. They took us to two snorkeling spots and just let us take everything in. Their crew was with us at all times but allowed us to have freedom and explore. After those first spots, they took us to the sandbar. Sting rays met us at the boat and they gave the boys bait to feed the sting rays. We were on a 7 day cruise with multiple excursions but this experience and atmosphere was all of our favorites. Then they gave us guacamole that was to die for, beautiful fruit and literally the best margaritas I have ever had. All the tours around us were jealous. While everyone was on a smaller boat with multiple people that they didn’t know, we were living it up and constantly laughing. Once we were headed in, the marina was closed. Instead of having us sit and wait, they took us to another spot to snorkel. Come on! Such an amazing time! Growing up on boats, we know how much work these guys put in to make it special for us. We will be back!! Side note: Having a bathroom on the boat is always great! Was very appreciated haha. Also grabbing a taxi back to the port was a breeze.

Response from Charter operator

Thank you Caisey, We hope to see you back on the island soon Regards

Compare similar fishing charters

Current
Aquadventures Cozumel “Why Not?”
4.6
/5
17 reviews
30 ft
Group size 1 - 8
1 - 8
4 hour trip • 5 persons
US $550

Rating

4.6
17 reviews
4.4
Boat & Equipment
4.8
Captain & Crew
4.6
Boating Experience

All reviews (17)

Showing 1617 of 17 reviews
  • Kellie Einemo
    Kellie Einemo
    us
    Arizona, US
    Member since 2025
    4.7
    Verified

    Greatest Birthday EVER

    Half Day Trip – AM4 adults

    We surprised our son in law with a boat trip. He was so happy. We loved the special touch of them buying Kyle a cake without us asking.

    Response from Charter operator

    Thank you! We hope to see you back on the island soon Regards

  • Dave Urspringer
    Dave Urspringer
    Repeat boater
    us
    Minnesota, US
    Member since 2025
    2 trips
    2.0
    Verified

    Do not book on Black Duck !

    Half Day Trip – PM3 adults

    arrived Boat was broken left 45 minutes late which turned out fine. Paid for six hours. Captain with no communication very irritated because we were not fishing. We think took us back two hours early and then said we asked to go back. We went to book 6 hours and only gone for. He just didn’t wanna be out there any longer.

    Response from Charter operator

    Hi Dave, Thank you for your feedback. We’re truly sorry that parts of your experience did not meet your expectations, as this is not the level of service we aim to provide. On the day of your trip, there was an unexpected mechanical issue at departure, which caused a delay. While it was resolved quickly, we understand that waiting is never ideal and we appreciate your patience. We would also like to clarify that your reservation was for a 4-hour charter, and you were charged accordingly. Prior to departure, you expressed interest in visiting El Cielo, and we explained that this would require a longer charter. Unfortunately, the Harbor Master restricted access to the southern area of the island that day, including El Cielo, which is completely outside of our control. Despite these circumstances, the trip continued with snorkeling, beach time, and activities as planned. As a gesture of goodwill, we refunded your deposit in full, even though the charter was completed. We take great pride in our team, whose experience spans decades, and in consistently delivering high-quality experiences to our guests. We regret that this situation did not meet your expectations, and we sincerely wish you the best in your future travels. — Aquadventures Cozumel Team