Our family of six enjoyed the 8-hour excursion with Miguel, Juan and Freddy. They worked hard keeping the lines in the water and chasing the next catch. Although the bites were few, they worked hard to get us on the fish even though it was off-season. We snorkeled Columbia Reef and saw sharks, turtles,dolphins, ann eagle ray and so many different kinds of fish.
We visited El Ceilo for the starfish and sting rays that swam all around us. The crew was friendly, helpful, informative and put together a delicious lunch and beverage selection. This was definitely a 10/10.

We booked Why Not during our spring break. There were four of us, myself, my husband, 15 year old son and his best friend. We are from the coast in FL and all fish regularly. We booked with Pedro a 6 hour excursion. The plan was to go fishing a little and then go snorkeling. We had clear communication of where to meet and jumped straight onto the boat. In no time, they were putting lines in the water. Unfortunately it was very rough and I just couldn’t handle it. I tried to hold off because they were working so hard to get us a fish on the line. Once they realized I was sick, they quickly came up with a new plan. They took us to two snorkeling spots and just let us take everything in. Their crew was with us at all times but allowed us to have freedom and explore. After those first spots, they took us to the sandbar. Sting rays met us at the boat and they gave the boys bait to feed the sting rays. We were on a 7 day cruise with multiple excursions but this experience and atmosphere was all of our favorites. Then they gave us guacamole that was to die for, beautiful fruit and literally the best margaritas I have ever had. All the tours around us were jealous. While everyone was on a smaller boat with multiple people that they didn’t know, we were living it up and constantly laughing. Once we were headed in, the marina was closed. Instead of having us sit and wait, they took us to another spot to snorkel. Come on! Such an amazing time! Growing up on boats, we know how much work these guys put in to make it special for us. We will be back!! Side note: Having a bathroom on the boat is always great! Was very appreciated haha. Also grabbing a taxi back to the port was a breeze.

We had an amazing day on the Why Not! We started the day by fishing! The first mate was incredibly helpful. We caught 5 barracuda! It was so much fun! The captain used one of the fish to make ceviche for our lunch! We then visited a very private beach that was lovely and quiet! It was the perfect day with an awesome crew! Worth every penny! Communication in planning was perfect! Just do it!!!!

We truly enjoyed our day and would highly recommend the “Why Not”.  They were very knowledgeable and helpful with everything!  Great lunch, too!

Amazing day trip!

From the chats after booking to the captain and crew being early (like us!), I cannot say enough great things about our day on Why Not!!

We caught 5 huge barracuda and swam with over 10 rays - overall they best day in Cozumel with the best crew!