Fishing in Alligator Reef

11 boats available

The best out of 11 deals in Alligator Reef - enter dates to check availability

Top Fishing in Alligator Reef

Fishing in Alligator Reef

Loading...

Alligator Reef

5.0
/5
Based on 126 reviews by boaters

What boaters said about Fishing

  • 5.0
    /5
    (Special 2 hour trip for Jim Dowling)

    great trip

    Matt is a captain with a ton of experience and knowledge of the waters around upper matecombe key/islamorada. i look forward to a great fishing trip out in the near future! Jim D
    Jim D.
    Jim D.
    Reviewed on Oct 12, 2026
  • 5.0
    /5
    (Private Snorkel Charter (4hr /AM))

    Family fun fishing!

    Booked a trip to go fishing with my family and ended up with my daughter and my daughter-in-law and myself. We could not have had a better time if we tried. The captain was fantastic! Captain Eddie made sure we were all comfortable, had equipment ready to go, filleted all the fish we caught. This was an awesome experience, for anybody with a lot of fishing experience, like myself, or my daughters, who had a little experience!
    Timothy N.
    Timothy N.
    Reviewed on Apr 16, 2026
  • 5.0
    /5
    (Sunset cruise, departure time varie)

    March boating trip

    Captain Jim is the best . Took us out reef fishing and followed up with a sunset cruise at night . Treats you like family . Will Definitely come back and hook up with Captain Jim
    RAYMOND J.
    RAYMOND J.
    Reviewed on Mar 26, 2026
  • 5.0
    /5
    (Private Snorkel Charter (4hr / PM))

    Best Boat Guide in the keys!!

    We had an amazing time out on the water with Captain Matt! Our family trip included snorkeling, hanging out at the sandbar, and even a little fishing—there was something for everyone to enjoy. We actually forgot to bring towels, but Captain Matt had us covered, which really shows how thoughtful and prepared he is. The whole experience was smooth, relaxing, and a lot of fun from start to finish. Highly recommend if you’re looking for a great day on the water with family!
    Nicholas M.
    Nicholas M.
    Reviewed on Mar 24, 2026
  • 5.0
    /5
    (Private Snorkel Charter (4hr /AM))

    Trip with granddaughter

    Captain Matt was fantastic. We had a wonderful time out on the water, knowable, snorkeling, fishing and swimming. Hit all the marks. Highly recommend using Bamboo Charter and we be going with them the next time we in the Keys.
    Jay Z.
    Jay Z.
    Reviewed on Nov 4, 2025

Top Fishing Destinations