28 ft6Key West Conchlife ChartersStock Island: 12.6 miles from Sugarloaf Keys5.0/5(9 external reviews)+2Trips up toUS $1,049
24 ft64.9(6)Good Times Key West 24’ Center Console.Key West: 26 min drive from Sugarloaf Keys+2Trips up toUS $1,000
20 ft64.9(14)Private Sand Bar trip🌞 Sorry No Fishing.Key West: 15 min drive from Sugarloaf Keys+6Trips up toUS $1,000
25 ft6Chastain Charters for ChristSummerland Key: 10.2 miles from Sugarloaf Keys+2Trips up toUS $1,000
4 ft84.7(1)Paradise Boat Rentals Key WestStock Island: 12.6 miles from Sugarloaf KeysTrips up toUS $1,000
24 ft65.0(97)Living Like Larry ChartersMarathon: 46 min drive from Sugarloaf Keys+9Trips up toUS $950